You are missing the point of this conversation. You were suggesting that your brother in law said the stuff ISIS does is in no way justified by Muhammad and the Quran. And yet...
What I said was "My brother-in-law would say that Muhammed would condemn the actions of ISIS". This is because my brother-in-law is one of those that believes Muhammed was attacked and that he had to go to war to defend himself. His actions were those of self-defense. ISIS actions are those of an aggressor.
If you read the citations many of those he ordered assassinated were people who were simply critical of him, or who wrote mocking poems of him or otherwise disrespected him. From this springs the almost universal belief among Muslims that it is forbidden to mock the prophet, and in most places, the proper punishment is death.
I don't trust that this is true; too many of the sources you rely on have a clearly anti-Islam bias. But I'm feeling too lazy and disinterested to spend time debunking it, particularly since you've given me so much more current stuff to debunk below.
And yet you can see where ISIS gets its justification for burning people alive.
Yes, there is plenty in Islam to justify all kinds of atrocities. There is also plenty in the Bible to justify atrocities, which some Christians have also used historically and still use currently. I know you'll dismiss those Christian activities as irrelevant so you can pretend that what ISIS does and their claims around it are something new and different and exceptionally evil in the world.
Against Muslims, yes.
If you say so, though I really don't trust much of what you say when it comes to Islam or Egyptians.
But wasn't he the prophet of God? Shouldn't he be above the kind of vicious, carnal brutality of ordinary, barbarous soldiers? Did you ever hear of Jesus Christ taking slaves or raping women? And if Muhammed was able to **** captive non-Muslim women why shouldn't ISIS? For that matter, given the division of the world into the house of peace (muslims) and the house of war (everyone not a muslim) basically any infidel woman is fair game.
What you should be paying attention to is what the vast majority of Muslims say about ISIS: It does not represent Islam and it does not follow the teachings of Islam, as far as they are concerned.
Of course ISIS can find justification for whatever it is they are doing, but that doesn't mean that every single Muslim who disagrees with them must be wrong. That is just your anti-Islam bias, and continuing tendency to smear all Muslims with the ISIS brush.
And yet, when we see what surveys say of attitudes among Egyptian Muslims we see overwhelming support for the deaths of apostates (86%) and blasphemers, for the death by stoning of adulterers (81%) and for Sharia law (84%), with 70% explicitly supporting the violent aspects of Sharia, like beheadings and cutting off body parts. We see Christians constantly attacked and murdered, their churches burned down, homosexuality illegal, over 90% of women subjected to female genital mutilation, and massive anti-semitism. So maybe your brother in law is wildly out of step with the rest of Egypt, or maybe he's just telling you what you want to hear.
These claims are what I feel inclined to research, using some logic and common sense.
In Egypt, homosexuality is not illegal, but they do round up and jail homosexuals under other laws like "lewdness", similar to what Canada was doing in the 1970s. This is wrong, I agree.
(By the way, I notice that you are no longer claiming that they favor putting homosexuals to death, since I pointed out that the question asked was "Do you think a Muslim can be homosexual?" and not "Do you think homosexuals should be put to death?" This tendency of yours to overstate even your own sources is why I feel justified in dismissing or challenging what you claim about Muslims and Egypt.)
I am assuming you are referring to this survey:
http://www.pewforum.org/2013/04/30/the-worlds-muslims-religion-politics-society-beliefs-about-sharia/,
First, how many Egyptian Muslims think Sharia should be the law of the land, according to the Pew Survey? 74%.
How many of that 74% think Sharia should apply to everyone, not just Muslims? Again, 74%.
How many of the Muslims who think Sharia Law should apply to everyone also believe in the most extreme form of Sharia law? 70%
So what we have is that is that really, 38% - 47%, or less than half of Egyptian Muslims - support things like cutting off of hands/death to apostates, stoning for adultery etc. That's a far cry from the claim you've made above, isn't it? Still very bad, for sure, but clearly my brother-in-law is not out of step with the social attitudes of his country.
And please note also, that regardless of what a Pew Research survey says, the law of Egypt does not allow for any of those more extreme forms of Sharia. For example, according to Wikipedia, Article 98f regarding blasphemy calls for jail sentences of 6 months or more, and a fine of 1000 pounds, and it applies to all faiths, not just Islam. The penalty for adultery for women is 2 years imprisonment and for men, 6 months. No stoning allowed.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blasphemy_law_in_Egypthttps://www.madamasr.com/en/2015/03/09/feature/society/fight-the-man-laws-that-help-women-and-laws-that-hurt-them/
I am not defending these practices, by the way, only pointing out hyperbolic claims you've made about Egypt.
Persecution against Coptic Christians. This is definitely true; government policies are biased against Christians and extremists often target Christians. Nonetheless, the majority of Muslims live peacefully with Christians and condemn attacks against them.
Anti-Semitism: Agreed, anti-Semitism exists in Egypt. At the same time, my brother-in-law says that it's not Jewish people so much as Israeli policy. Nonetheless, there is no denying the anti-Semitism that exists in Egypt.
FGM: Is illegal in Egypt, albeit not well enforced. Nonetheless, the incidence of FGM has been declining and may now be as low as 50%, as per the link I posted yesterday. Still too many, but the claim that 97% of women undergo FGM is no longer accurate.
Please note that nowhere did I say either Egyptians or Muslims were paragons of virtue, that Egypt was a wonderful place to live, or that there were no problems either among their attitudes or laws. I merely added a touch of reality to the anti-Islamic rhetoric you are all too eager to believe to support your anti-Muslim stance.