Author Topic: Woke Culture  (Read 30613 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Black Dog

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 9183
  • Location: Deathbridge
Re: Woke Culture
« Reply #480 on: December 02, 2021, 09:23:02 am »
That's right and the devil is in the specifics.
It simply means anyone can see when outcomes are unequal where it's most obvious, which is usually after the fact and when it's too late.

I guess I should have said the problem is power but the solution needs to be applied at the other end of the pipe from which the outcomes are flowing. You're certainly not the only progressive who doesn't want to go there. Why remains a mystery to me.

It's a mystery because your contention is wrong. Moderates, centrists and conservatives aren't that interested in campaign finance reform or expanding voting rights or any other issues that are upstream from their outcomes.
« Last Edit: December 02, 2021, 10:37:56 am by Black Dog »

Offline Black Dog

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 9183
  • Location: Deathbridge
Re: Woke Culture
« Reply #481 on: December 02, 2021, 09:39:33 am »
I agree with this.  The danger is in losing the moderates and left-of-center types.  They can be red-pilled, and many already have.  Moderates can get on board with demonizing racists and sexists, it's different when whites and men as a group get demonized, it can get people's backs up so they feel they need to defend themselves, same when progressives go over the line to where it tramples on other's rights.

The danger is losing people like Bill Maher or Kimmy to the right.  Elections are won by the moderate swing-voters, the **** left and right folks will never change their minds.  US voters elected Bill Clinton, then George Bush, then Obama, then Trump.  Canadians elected Chretien, then Harper, then Trudeau.  The moderates determine everything.  Kimmy isn't a conservative, but she feels she has no choice but to defend her own rights when she feels the rights of others are intruding on them.  I'm also not a conservative btw, I voted for Trudeau in 2015, I would have voted for Obama and Bernie Sanders, i'm probably moderate to right-of-center socially on lots of things but i'm left-of-center economically.

As I've said many times before, this only happens when people swallow the right's framing and it happens because of the way the right wing misinfotainment complex controls the narrative which gets laundered even through the so called liberal media.

Whether its trans issues or the CRT panic, the formula goes like this:

Right wing dark money group-->coordinated campaign on Boomer Facebook-->Tucker Carlson's White Power Hour-->angry parents at school board meetings or wtv-->CNN/MSNBC-->comfortable liberal moderates

Hell, your post here uncritically repeats Tucker Carlson's claim, itself pulled from a longstanding white supremacist mantra, that "white people and men are demonized" by anti-racists.

It doesn't help that mainstream liberals are incapable of pushing back against those narratives (how many liberals -have i seen arguing against the CRT panic by saying "oh, CRT is a legal framework that isn't taught in schools" instead of "these whackjobs really want to ban talking about racism and reading Martin Luther King JR."

« Last Edit: December 02, 2021, 10:40:35 am by Black Dog »

Offline eyeball

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 1140
Re: Woke Culture
« Reply #482 on: December 02, 2021, 10:39:09 am »
It's a mystery because your contention is wrong.
How so? Access to politicians behind closed doors is equal or it just doesn't have any effect on outcomes when access is weighted towards a small powerful influential group of lobbyists?

Quote
Moderates, centrists and conservatives aren't that interested in campaign finance reform or expanding voting rights or any other issues that are upstream from their outcomes.
They seem even less concerned with accountability.  I sense some sort of strong-man complex - a servile acquiescence to authority.  I think you're wrong to assume this is a nothing-burger, I happen to think its directly tied to why so much gets the fake-news label these days and why faith in governance is in such steep decline virtually everywhere around the world.  These are dangerous times and we're fiddling like proverbial Romans.   
« Last Edit: December 02, 2021, 10:58:30 am by eyeball »

Offline Queefer Sutherland

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 10252
Re: Woke Culture
« Reply #483 on: December 02, 2021, 12:27:17 pm »
It's a mystery because your contention is wrong. Moderates, centrists and conservatives aren't that interested in campaign finance reform or expanding voting rights or any other issues that are upstream from their outcomes.

Total nonsense.  The ones not interested in finance reform are libertarians or the conservatives that are pieces of crap or just corrupt.  There's also many politicians on the left and left of center, including Liberals and Democrats and I'm sure even NDP, who don't care about campaign finance reform because politicians of all stripes are corrupt.  The left is certainly better than the right of this but the issue isn't purely ideological, it's one of power and corruption.

But you're right in that there's many conservatives and even centrists who are self-serving a-holes.  You'll find that on the left too but it's more of a rightwing thing because they value liberty over fairness or security.
« Last Edit: December 02, 2021, 12:29:49 pm by Nipples Von Graham »
"Nipples is one of the great minds of our time!" - Bubbermiley

Offline Black Dog

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 9183
  • Location: Deathbridge
Re: Woke Culture
« Reply #484 on: December 02, 2021, 12:48:02 pm »
How so? Access to politicians behind closed doors is equal or it just doesn't have any effect on outcomes when access is weighted towards a small powerful influential group of lobbyists?

I'm talking about this claim:

Quote
...the solution needs to be applied at the other end of the pipe from which the outcomes are flowing. You're certainly not the only progressive who doesn't want to go there.

I really have no idea where you get that from, that progressives are only interested in tweaking outcomes and not structural change.

Quote
They seem even less concerned with accountability.  I sense some sort of strong-man complex - a servile acquiescence to authority.  I think you're wrong to assume this is a nothing-burger, I happen to think its directly tied to why so much gets the fake-news label these days and why faith in governance is in such steep decline virtually everywhere around the world.  These are dangerous times and we're fiddling like proverbial Romans.   

I didn't say it was nothing?

Offline Queefer Sutherland

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 10252
Re: Woke Culture
« Reply #485 on: December 02, 2021, 12:49:11 pm »
As I've said many times before, this only happens when people swallow the right's framing and it happens because of the way the right wing misinfotainment complex controls the narrative which gets laundered even through the so called liberal media.

Whether its trans issues or the CRT panic, the formula goes like this:

Right wing dark money group-->coordinated campaign on Boomer Facebook-->Tucker Carlson's White Power Hour-->angry parents at school board meetings or wtv-->CNN/MSNBC-->comfortable liberal moderates

I'm not saying the above doesn't happen.  I'm saying the left needs to check itself before it wrecks itself, which it already has done a wonderful job of doing.  The left and right are both a giant mess right now filled with more wingnuts than ever before.  It's quite amazing that everyone seems to be going insane.

Your issue is that you're always a hair-frigger from retreating into your defensive position of all-out left vs right warfare and always blaming the other side for everything and always assuming the worst intentions from them and not bothering to empathize or actually listen to them one bit.  The anger in most of your posts is wrothing.  The sad thing is that you're obviously intelligent and capable of civil discussion but you're knee deep as a soldier in the culture war I guess.  This is true of a great many people.  The problem i think is a lack of empathy among everyone.  You're part of the problem, sorry.

What sucks is these issues are all very emotional and enraging and I get it, but we have to be better than this.  We have to get off our teams and call out BS where we see it instead of doubling-down.

Quote
Hell, your post here uncritically repeats Tucker Carlson's claim, itself pulled from a longstanding white supremacist mantra, that "white people and men are demonized" by anti-racists.

Not everything criticizing racism by white people is crapping on white people as a whole.  But some of it is, and that's what i'm talking about it.  There's a point where it goes from an attack on racism to a condemnation of an entire group, and if done with bad intentions or just done poorly can get even well-meaning people's back up.  All i'm saying is the left needs to sometimes check itself before it wrecks itself, you've even admitted the left can sometimes go too far.  White people have to own their sh*, and that goes for everyone too if we're all in this together.

Quote
It doesn't help that mainstream liberals are incapable of pushing back against those narratives (how many liberals -have i seen arguing against the CRT panic by saying "oh, CRT is a legal framework that isn't taught in schools" instead of "these whackjobs really want to ban talking about racism and reading Martin Luther King JR."

I'm sure there's some legit racists that want to ban MLK, but there's also a lot that just don't like CRT for the exact reasons they say.
"Nipples is one of the great minds of our time!" - Bubbermiley

Offline Black Dog

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 9183
  • Location: Deathbridge
Re: Woke Culture
« Reply #486 on: December 02, 2021, 02:11:42 pm »
I'm not saying the above doesn't happen.  I'm saying the left needs to check itself before it wrecks itself, which it already has done a wonderful job of doing.  The left and right are both a giant mess right now filled with more wingnuts than ever before.  It's quite amazing that everyone seems to be going insane.

And my point is this isn't true, unless you think perception and reality are the same thing. The extreme left is marginal, the extreme right is one of the two major political parties in the U.S. and a massive portion of its base. These are not the same. Your issue is that you are so invested in your identity as "reasonable centrist" that you can't see the asymmetry of power in the left right divide.

Quote
Your issue is that you're always a hair-frigger from retreating into your defensive position of all-out left vs right warfare and always blaming the other side for everything and always assuming the worst intentions from them and not bothering to empathize or actually listen to them one bit. The anger in most of your posts is wrothing.  The sad thing is that you're obviously intelligent and capable of civil discussion but you're knee deep as a soldier in the culture war I guess.  This is true of a great many people.  The problem i think is a lack of empathy among everyone.  You're part of the problem, sorry.

There is a war on, but it's not left vs right. It's the right vs democracy and indeed the very concept of society.

As for the not listening or empathizing part, that's bogus. I listen and when people tell me who they are, I believe them.

Quote
What sucks is these issues are all very emotional and enraging and I get it, but we have to be better than this.  We have to get off our teams and call out BS where we see it instead of doubling-down.

If you want to call out BS, then you should call out the BS that wokeness is a significant problem.

Quote
Not everything criticizing racism by white people is crapping on white people as a whole.  But some of it is, and that's what i'm talking about it.  There's a point where it goes from an attack on racism to a condemnation of an entire group, and if done with bad intentions or just done poorly can get even well-meaning people's back up.

"Some" of it is? How much, exactly?

Quote
.  All i'm saying is the left needs to sometimes check itself before it wrecks itself, you've even admitted the left can sometimes go too far.

The thing is, when "the left gos too far" it's, like, college kids being annoying. When the right goes too far, it looks like Jan. 6 at the Capitol. Yet the former is treated as a far greater threat than the latter by "moderates" who seem to regard right wing extremism as something inevitable and uncontrollable, like hurricanes or wildfires as opposed to the work of individuals with agency.

Quote
I'm sure there's some legit racists that want to ban MLK, but there's also a lot that just don't like CRT for the exact reasons they say.

And what reasons are those?
« Last Edit: December 02, 2021, 02:13:22 pm by Black Dog »

Offline Queefer Sutherland

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 10252
Re: Woke Culture
« Reply #487 on: December 02, 2021, 02:42:34 pm »
And my point is this isn't true, unless you think perception and reality are the same thing. The extreme left is marginal, the extreme right is one of the two major political parties in the U.S. and a massive portion of its base. These are not the same. Your issue is that you are so invested in your identity as "reasonable centrist" that you can't see the asymmetry of power in the left right divide.

So again you're pitting the right and left vs each other as if it's some p!ssing contest as to who is the bigger a-holes.  Yes we know the right are bigger a-holes.  That doesn't mean the left's sh!t don't stink.

Also, the only source of power isn't just held in political office.  People are changing how people are hired and fired for political/ideological reasons or if they don't get a vaccine, sorry but denying employment decisions and school admissions etc are political too.

Quote
There is a war on, but it's not left vs right. It's the right vs democracy and indeed the very concept of society.

No it's the loony left vs the racist right and each polarized minority is trying to recruit followers from the bystanders in the middle.

Quote
As for the not listening or empathizing part, that's bogus. I listen and when people tell me who they are, I believe them.

I was just effing with you and you believed me for some reason.  Get over it.

Quote
If you want to call out BS, then you should call out the BS that wokeness is a significant problem.

No.
Quote
The thing is, when "the left gos too far" it's, like, college kids being annoying. When the right goes too far, it looks like Jan. 6 at the Capitol. Yet the former is treated as a far greater threat than the latter by "moderates" who seem to regard right wing extremism as something inevitable and uncontrollable, like hurricanes or wildfires as opposed to the work of individuals with agency.

Do you actually believe this crap?  I think you're a rabid leftwing nutter.  Somewhere in there there's a reasonable person yearning to get out.

Quote
And what reasons are those?

Some think that CRT and/or its proponents slot all individuals into groups and often assign group blame, group guilt, and group resentment for actions that individuals themselves had nothing to do with.  I don't have a problem with CRT in general but I believe sometimes it goes nutty, because again some on the left are nutbars.
"Nipples is one of the great minds of our time!" - Bubbermiley

Offline Black Dog

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 9183
  • Location: Deathbridge
Re: Woke Culture
« Reply #488 on: December 02, 2021, 02:57:21 pm »
So again you're pitting the right and left vs each other as if it's some p!ssing contest as to who is the bigger a-holes. Yes we know the right are bigger a-holes.  That doesn't mean the left's sh!t don't stink.

Not the issue.

Quote
Also, the only source of power isn't just held in political office.

Yeah no kidding. What's your point?

Quote
People are changing how people are hired and fired for political/ideological reasons or if they don't get a vaccine, sorry but denying employment decisions and school admissions etc are political too

Anecdotes, anecdotes everywhere. Where's your rigorous social science research to back this up?

I'll also point out that vaccination wasn't political until the right wing decided to make it part of their ongoing culture war.

Quote
No it's the loony left vs the racist right and each polarized minority is trying to recruit followers from the bystanders in the middle.

I think you genuinely believe this, which shows an astonishing lack of awareness of the world around us.

Quote
I was just effing with you and you believed me for some reason.  Get over it.

Oh you think I was talking about your pretending to be Black thing? LOL no, not everything is about you. I'm talking about the notion that if we just talk to and empathize with right wing people, we'd see they aren't crazy. I've tried it, it doesn't work.

Quote
Do you actually believe this crap?  I think you're a rabid leftwing nutter.  Somewhere in there there's a reasonable person yearning to get out.

It's telling to me that you go to personal attacks here since clearly you don't have an actual rebuttal.

Quote
Some think that CRT and/or its proponents slot all individuals into groups and often assign group blame, group guilt, and group resentment for actions that individuals themselves had nothing to do with. 

I know that's what they think but that's because they are lying, stupid or both. If you want to see what they are actually objecting to,  here's a formal complaint filed by an activist group called Moms for Liberty claiming that four young-elementary books violated the Tennessee's new anti-CRT law. They repeat a lot of the claims you make, but if you read the complaints, you'll see what they are actually fighting is presenting children with historical facts that might make them feel bad. And that's the point of these laws and the anti-CRT campaign: treating white people's feelings as precious things to be protected at all costs. And thus seeing Norman Rockwell's painting of Ruby Bridges being escorted to school by federal marshals is basically the same thing as being told white people today are responsible for slavery.

Quote
I don't have a problem with CRT in general but I believe sometimes it goes nutty, because again some on the left are nutbars.

I commend your honesty in admitting you will fall for anything that confirms your biases.
« Last Edit: December 02, 2021, 03:36:20 pm by Black Dog »

Offline Black Dog

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 9183
  • Location: Deathbridge
Re: Woke Culture
« Reply #489 on: December 02, 2021, 04:43:47 pm »
Since Graham mentioned Bill Maher, I thought I'd post this.

New Rule: Bill Maher Should Look in the Mirror

Quote
Maher is not just unfairly, and hypocritically, defining the Democratic Party with backbencher votes and stray tweets from woke progressives. He is actively pushing false information about what these progressives are actually doing.

During his turn on Cuomo Prime Time, Maher said, “When you’re doing something that sounds like a headline in The Onion, that’s when you’ve gone too far, you know? Land of Lincoln cancels Lincoln. That really happened. They tore down Lincoln’s—Lincoln isn’t good enough for them. Seattle, the city council voted to decriminalize crime. This is an Onion headline. I saw one, very recently, maybe babies should vote. It’s what I mean about the ‘Party of No Common Sense.’”

Every one of these examples is misinformation.

This is exactly the phenomenon I've been talking about: some fringe idea bubbles up and its seized upon by bad faith interlocutors as some new leftist orthodoxy no matter how inconsequential because they know the lie ("lefties want to cancel Abe Lincoln!") will find firmer purchase than the banal reality ("City of Chicago to review its collection of monuments").


Online Michael Hardner

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 12528
Re: Woke Culture
« Reply #490 on: December 02, 2021, 06:03:07 pm »

This is exactly the phenomenon I've been talking about: some fringe idea bubbles up and its seized upon by bad faith interlocutors as some new leftist orthodoxy no matter how inconsequential because they know the lie 

Yep.

I've been thinking about this phenomenon lately, as a facet of 'seeing everything'.  We can see ALL the Republicans and ALL the Democrats.  As when HD TV came on the scene, we now see the creases and wrinkles on the faces of the newscasters too well.

Online Michael Hardner

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 12528
Re: Woke Culture
« Reply #491 on: December 02, 2021, 06:06:17 pm »
So maybe the thing to be done is to separate comments between:

-masses
-informed public
-outer circle of power
-institutions and their representatives

Or somesuch.  The web brings people like Howard Dean into a questionable status.  The obfuscation makes it hard to discern between messages and audiences.

Offline Queefer Sutherland

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 10252
Re: Woke Culture
« Reply #492 on: December 02, 2021, 09:40:00 pm »
Not the issue.

Then why do you keep making it an issue?

Quote
Yeah no kidding. What's your point?

The point is your point is incorrect.

Quote
Anecdotes, anecdotes everywhere. Where's your rigorous social science research to back this up?

I'm not denying people their basic legal rights, i'm just a mouth on the internet, I don't have a responsibility to put the work in because i'm not discriminating against anybody.

Quote
I think you genuinely believe this, which shows an astonishing lack of awareness of the world around us.

Doubling down on "my team's sh*t don't stink"?

Quote
Oh you think I was talking about your pretending to be Black thing? LOL no, not everything is about you. I'm talking about the notion that if we just talk to and empathize with right wing people, we'd see they aren't crazy. I've tried it, it doesn't work.

There's a lot of people on the right that are indeed crazy and totally unreasonable, there's others that are.  You've put them all in the corner and painted them with a broad brush to hate on them, which is exactly how racists think btw.

What you keep doing is find the worst example and label that as the norm that everyone follows.  It's just bad faith nonsense.  The world is much more complex than your black-and-white world.

Quote
I know that's what they think but that's because they are lying, stupid or both. If you want to see what they are actually objecting to,  here's a formal complaint filed by an activist group called Moms for Liberty claiming that four young-elementary books violated the Tennessee's new anti-CRT law. They repeat a lot of the claims you make, but if you read the complaints, you'll see what they are actually fighting is presenting children with historical facts that might make them feel bad. And that's the point of these laws and the anti-CRT campaign: treating white people's feelings as precious things to be protected at all costs. And thus seeing Norman Rockwell's painting of Ruby Bridges being escorted to school by federal marshals is basically the same thing as being told white people today are responsible for slavery.

Yeah their examples are legit stupid i agree.  And yet I agree with the first part of it.  The people who wrote this are dumb.  Then again, it also goes back to my point about moralizing in the classroom.
"Nipples is one of the great minds of our time!" - Bubbermiley

Offline Queefer Sutherland

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 10252
Re: Woke Culture
« Reply #493 on: December 02, 2021, 09:55:57 pm »
Since Graham mentioned Bill Maher, I thought I'd post this.

New Rule: Bill Maher Should Look in the Mirror

This is exactly the phenomenon I've been talking about: some fringe idea bubbles up and its seized upon by bad faith interlocutors as some new leftist orthodoxy no matter how inconsequential because they know the lie ("lefties want to cancel Abe Lincoln!") will find firmer purchase than the banal reality ("City of Chicago to review its collection of monuments").

This is exactly what you do with the right.  Like bang on.  This is what this author did with Maher.  Your head is so far up your own arse you can't see anything but poo.

Fringe wokesters and alt-righters are both a bunch of crazy people.  I'll even say that the frothing rightwingers are at least 25% crazier than the loons on the left just so you don't go on a rant.  But go ahead, defend "your side" of the giant pile of idea feces.

Even if Maher is a hypocrite and might say something wrong or stupid who cares?  He's often bang on with so many points.  This dude is just trying to discredit him because his common sense makes him cry.  Bill Maher could shoot grammas and ra.pe babies and he'd still be right on a lot of his points.
"Nipples is one of the great minds of our time!" - Bubbermiley
Funny Funny x 1 Dumb Dumb x 1 View List

Offline Black Dog

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 9183
  • Location: Deathbridge
Re: Woke Culture
« Reply #494 on: December 03, 2021, 09:56:26 am »
Then why do you keep making it an issue?

Because silly centrists like you pretend they're the same thing when they aren't.

"They're both a-holes" is a self-serving false equivalency, the only purpose of which is to show everyone how you are a Sensible Moderate who transcends such radical ideas.

Quote
The point is your point is incorrect.

It's not. You just struggle with politics beyond simplistic definitions tied to partisan labels.

Quote
I'm not denying people their basic legal rights, i'm just a mouth on the internet, I don't have a responsibility to put the work in because i'm not discriminating against anybody.

"I don't have to back up my claims." in other words. An easy way to spew a bunch on nonsense and then slither away.

People have always, always been hired and fired for political/ideological reasons, you only see it as a problem when it's done for woke reasons. Why?

Quote
Doubling down on "my team's sh*t don't stink"?

I keep stating my thesis that the woke panic is overblown, that the type of wokeness you find so offensive barely exists IRL and that woke people of that sort lack real institutional power but you simply can't grasp that point. It's maddening.

Quote
There's a lot of people on the right that are indeed crazy and totally unreasonable, there's others that are.  You've put them all in the corner and painted them with a broad brush to hate on them, which is exactly how racists think btw.

What you keep doing is find the worst example and label that as the norm that everyone follows.  It's just bad faith nonsense.  The world is much more complex than your black-and-white world.

If there are any reasonable American conservatives who have not been captured by the violent conspiratorial cult side of the party, they are either insignificant in number of too scared to actually speak up, which means they are irrelevant as a political force and to the the purposes of our discussion. But you keep trying to turn what should be a political discussion into a personal one and i'm not really interested in your ham fisted attempts to pathologize me.

Quote
Yeah their examples are legit stupid i agree.  And yet I agree with the first part of it.  The people who wrote this are dumb.  Then again, it also goes back to my point about moralizing in the classroom.

I again must remind you that when I first posted about these kinds of laws, you had no problem with them even after i said they were intentionally broad for a reason so as to capture any material anyone disagreed with. And these parents would 100% agree with you about moralizing in the classroom; it is in fact the basis of their complaint.
« Last Edit: December 03, 2021, 03:39:58 pm by Black Dog »
Like Like x 1 View List