Of course this is nonsense, but you're entitled to your opinion.
The question was, is questioning our immigration policies necessarily taking a cue from the "Trump playbook"? Can you question our immigration policies without being seen as a racist xenophobe etc?
You're creating a strawman: nobody claims that any and all questioning of immigration is a cue from the Trump playbook. That's an extreme position that you've created to imply that any and all questioning of immigration is valid.
Immigration should be questioned
in a rational and intelligent way, based on observable facts and data. Hysteria over Islamofascists flooding our gates is bullshit, especially when a large proportion of the Muslims we admit are fleeing the secular and political violence they face in their homelands. Hell, you can't even look at a public discussion about immigration online without people conflating immigrants and refugees. The vast majority of commenters are completely unfamiliar with our immigration system and the laws that direct it.
So do you want me to admit that questioning the immigration system is NOT out of the Trump playbook? Sometimes it is. Sometimes it's not. The context and content of the arguments matters. There is no one black and white statement to be made about these kinds of complex issues.